Smartphone Notches Explained
- 15 January, 2021 07:33
Over the last two years, the inclusion of notched displays similar to that found in Apple’s iPhone X and iPhone XS have become a dominant but divisive trend in the world of modern smartphone design.
Some love the notch. Others hate it. Nevertheless, if you’re confused about why notches are a thing at all, here’s a quick primer on everything you need to know about smartphone notches.
What is a notched display?
The term notched display refers to a smartphone screen that features an irregular shape due to a cutout on one of the device’s edges (usually the uppermost one) rather than a regular, rectangular screen.
Though the exact purpose of each notch is different, display cutouts are often used to house sensors, speakers and front-facing camera modules.
Where did the first notched display come from?
Although Apple’s iPhone X served to popularize the notched display, Essential’s PH-1 smartphone was the first notable device to incorporate a notched display.
The Essential PH-1 was announced in May 2017 and released in August 2017 to mixed reviews. The iPhone X wasn’t officially announced until September and featured a slightly wider notch design. Nevertheless, many credit Apple with popularizing notched displays.
Why do modern smartphones have notches?
Opting for a notched display is a design choice that allows manufacturers to achieve a higher screen-to-body ratio, smaller physical form-factor and offer the user more screen space by migrating the Android status bar into the screen space surrounding the notch.
When combined with thin bezels and curved displays, notches allow for new smartphone designs that come closer to a sort of all-screen ideal that can plied as an advantage over the competition.
The actual real-world benefits of smartphone notches are slim. A phone with a notch doesn't feel terribly better or different to one without a display cutout. Nevertheless, if you’re marketing or looking for a point of difference between one product and the competition, it’s easy to see (and sell) more screen space as better than less screen space.
The catch here is that there's always going to be a chance that the app you're running on your device might not have been optimised for notched displays. This can lead to frustrating situations where you can’t access part of a critical part of the screen due to the positioning of the cutout.
To try and reduce these problems, Google introduced several new rules for Android developers in 2018. They mandate that a single edge can contain at most one cutout and a maximum of two cutouts total. They also ask that cutouts not be placed on the longer edges of the display.
The implementation of these guidelines has reduced some of the growing pains around notched displays but not eliminated them outright.
What Kinds of Notch Are There?
Though it wasn’t technically the first notched smartphone display to hit the market, the wedge-like notch found in the iPhone X and subsequent Apple’s devices was the first such screen to break into the popular consciousness. It's by far the most well-known type of notched display out there. When people think smartphone notch, they're usually thinking of this specific take on the formula.
After matching the notch design of Apple’s iPhone X hardware, many Android manufacturers saw an opportunity to further improve the screen-to-body ratio of their notched displays by cutting things further down to match - eventually ending up with the same ‘teardrop’ style cutout found in the Essential phone.
As with all notched displays, the advantage of a teardrop versus a wedge is that you’re getting slightly more screen space. However, opting for a teardrop display can sometimes lead to compromises on the front-facing camera. For example, Huawei’s Mate 20 features this design but loses the 3D Face Unlock found in the Mate 20 Pro as a result.
A prototype for a 5G Samsung smartphone shown off at a recent Qualcomm event featured a notch on the upper-right corner of the screen.
Though you'd think the outspoken reaction from notch-haters online might deter the company from embracing this particular layout in the future, they've gone ahead and put the world's first "Side-Notch" on the internal display of their new Galaxy Fold.
Whether it will stick around or remain a source of rare novelty remains unknown.
“The Double Notch”
Though there’s not a huge amount of practical reasons to do so, some vendors have even opted to include not one but two notches on their smartphones.
For obvious reasons, the amount of manufacturers embracing the concept of a double notch isn’t huge. This is mostly because the benefits of doing so aren’t super-clear. There was the Sharp’s Aquos R Compact, which used the lower-notch housed a traditional haptic fingerprint sensor.
As with all notches, it’s very case by case. Time will tell whether the argument for two notches can hold up to the scrutiny of everyday consumers or whether manufacturers will be able to minimise the tech involved to such a degree that the double notch becomes a thing of the past.
From 2019, smartphone manufacturers have seemingly settled on a new form of notched display that some call “the hole-punched display”, “circular cutout display” or“hole-display”. Regretfully, some manufacturers refer to this design as the 'dotch'.
Seen above, this type of notched display migrates the teardrop notch to the left or right of the display.
Whether or not this notch will prove successful remains to be seen. Like all notches, it presents new challenges for software developers. However, if a device’s screen-to-body ratio is paramount, those challenges are likely to be seen as worth surmounting by manufacturers.
After all, this desire to push for smaller and smaller devices with bigger and bigger screen is what got us to today’s landscape of notched displays.
The question of whether notches are here to stay and, if not, what a future without them might look like can be answered in a single phrase: under-display camera modules.
Similar to the in-display fingerprint sensors that have become a standard among Android devices in recent years, under-display camera modules promise to allow manufacturers to squeeze the front-facing camera underneath the screen itself. Oppo and others have shown off prototypes of what this might look like over the last few years, though no manufacturer has committed to bringing a product with this feature to market just yet.
Though early iterations of the under-display camera are likely to come with caveats when it comes to quality, this seems like a technology that is naturally going to replace most smartphone notches over time.
This article was originally published in January 2019 and updated in January 2021.